rebecca ([info]splinterjete) wrote,
@ 2008-03-24 19:25:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
change
this is a topic that i've been drawn to exploring. people are often focused on the 'change' that happens when one has bottom surgery. there's this mystique that's affixed to the colloquial image of bottom surgery. it takes on affectations like the 'sex change' or 'sex reassignment surgery'.

i find it ironic that people ask me, quite predictably, how my vagina - and presumably my opinions and relationship to her - is doing. people are often dismayed by my blase response. i'm sure most other women would concur with me that having a vagina is - unto itself - quite a forgetable component of one's day-to-day life. my momentary thoughts are not occupied by phrasings such as "wow.... vagina" or "me and my vagina are enjoying this latte". the presence of a penis, on the other hand, well that was pretty much on my mind all the time (and rarely - but sometimes - in a good way). of course, no one thought to ask me how i felt about my penis. now *that* would would have made for more prolific conversation!

now, before i develop a reputation of being a vagina-erasor, i will acknowledge that in certain contexts my vagina does become *significantly* less mundane, and that i should hope goes without saying.

all this time freed up from thinking about my genitals has really given me a lot of time to grow and dream. that, i feel, is the big *change* that accompanies bottom surgery.

i've also been pondering the way in which "change" is valued in our culture. it's quite contradictory, i've found.

as a culture, we seem obsessed with "change". this takes the shape of self-improvement and its various beasts (dieting, cosmetic surgery, compulsive exercise, and various rituals of purity and cleansing), in new year's resolutions, and in commercialism and the "change" that's implicity or explicitly promised when we make the purchase, whether it be travel, clothing, make-up etc...

ironically though, 'change' often can be held against someone. changing one's mind, taking a step backwards, making an unpredictable alteration to one's life, or acknowledging when a mistake is made. these things are often understood as being signs of weakness, mental illness, or simple immaturity.

some questions to ponder: what is the relationship between this seemingly contradictory way our culture relates to the concept of change. what does this mean for someone who 'changes' genders? what about for someone who comes out as queer in their 20s or in their 30s? what about for someone who decides to change their career? or who just has had enough of capitalism? are there intrinsically 'good' changes and 'bad' changes? does it depend on who does the changing and when?


~becca



(Post a new comment)


[info]jessie_c
2008-03-25 12:52 am UTC (link)
I think that the difference between a "good" change and a "bad" change is situational. Who does the changing, when it happens, why it happens and where it happens all play a part in determining whether a change is preceived as "good" or "bad". Also, whether a change is preceived as "bad" is almost invariably dependant on the observer. The person making the change would see any change they make as "good" otherwise why make it?

As far as my vagina goes? Meh, it's there and it's superior (for me) to what was there before. The first time I said "my vagina" it was a trip, but I don't obsess about it. I so hear you about having so much more time now that I don't constantly get reminded about the Donot Material. The mental peace is so worth it : )

(Reply to this)


[info]dale62676
2008-03-25 01:18 am UTC (link)
"me and my vagina are enjoying this latte"

That is freakin' fantastic! Lulz

Nice to see you on Facebook too, thanks for adding me. Your profile pic there is so cute! Will I see you at Camp Trans this year? Only 4 months away~ :)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]splinterjete
2008-03-25 01:24 am UTC (link)
"will i see you at ct?"

you betcha. i may not be a happy camper (cause i loathe campting), but i'll be there.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]changingone77
2008-03-25 03:09 am UTC (link)
Oh! I so wanna go to camp trans this year.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]aki_no_kaze
2008-03-25 03:06 am UTC (link)
"me and my vagina are enjoying this latte"

if you were it would make me wonder what you were doing with that latte!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]changingone77
2008-03-25 03:09 am UTC (link)
Lol, messy.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]jessie_c
2008-03-25 03:42 am UTC (link)
Warming her dilators of course. What else would she be doing?

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]transgressor
2008-03-25 04:10 am UTC (link)
i'm generally as ambivalent about my vagina as I was about my penis, save when genitals come into ...erm...play. be that peeing...or playing...it's then that I notice, if I notice, how much happier I am and how much more at home, in the new configuration.

(Reply to this)


[info]etherealgrace
2008-03-25 05:58 pm UTC (link)

ZOMG VAGINA!!!!11!11

Ahem... now that I've gotten that out of my system, please allow me to say that I agree with you wholeheartedly here. I've come to despise trans-related documentaries and the like that focus on bottom surgery as "completing" someone's transition. Utter nonsense.

Why does our society focus so much on bits that most people never see? Why is it that so many places demand that people have genital surgery before they can get their sex designation legally changed? It seems like we uphold the vagina as the epitome of female existence, and likewise the penis as the epitome of male existence, and so everything anyone does in transition prior to obtaining one of these items seems to pale in comparison. I think this attitude trivializes trans experience to a great degree, because it ignores the parts of transition that are often the toughest. The criteria for obtaining bottom surgery include having lived full-time for over a year, by which point the toughest hurdle is over. Unless someone is constantly in circumstances that require total nudity or anything close, bottom surgery will do nothing for passing.

So yeah... we seem to have this fetish for "transformation" as evidenced by shows like "Trading Spaces", "The Swan", and "Extreme Makeover". Our culture is fascinated by transformation of any sort, really, be it good or bad. The more dramatic the transformation, the more fascinating it is. Whether one reacts with wonder, revulsion, awe, or whatever else depends on one's viewpoint.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]sonjaaa
2008-03-26 07:24 pm UTC (link)
Hm, that's a very good observation, Mara.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]etherealgrace
2008-03-26 07:53 pm UTC (link)

Thanks. Also... I love the vowel chart avatar!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]minus70mv
2008-04-17 04:02 pm UTC (link)
"me and my vagina are enjoying this latte".
LOL. I don't know though, before I decaffed myself to get rid of anxiety I always thought of coffee as a sexual experience....
Change is inevitable in human relationships and the human experience. I live in what could be considered the "typical" family. I am married with two kids, and seem to be very much a "typical" american family. However, even that stable, "normal" seeming relationship is constantly evolving and changing, and in many ways that would have surprised me years ago. The qualities of good and bad are relative, and what would have seemed like a negative change 5 years ago I often find to be positive today, or conversely some stuff that would have seemed small then is HUGE now.
Did you really "change" genders? It seems to me that most of the trans people I know aren't so much changing as they are just being themselves? Granted, my knowledge in this area is second hand, and I am just wondering.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]splinterjete
2008-04-17 05:45 pm UTC (link)
okay, you build wheels and quit coffee!!!??? zowzers! you're super-man. seriously! i need some of *your* mojo. :)

i can't even imagine making my life function without coffee - and that you have kids too! wow, just wow.

of course i realize that there's other, more intrinsic motivators that we can draw strength from - obviously you've found them better than I.

and you're totally right about 'changing' genders. my gender is the one thing that hasn't changed. it's something that, perhaps surfaced would be a better metaphor over my life. there is a lot of change although its outward (which is the kind of change we almost exclusively value in our culture) so it seems like a bigger thing to everyone else than to me. f'sure.

thanks for your insights. ;)

~becca

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…